The Chicago suburbs have a quietly serious Italian restaurant scene. Some of it is the legacy of the Italian-American communities that settled in towns like Elmwood Park, Melrose Park, and along the North Shore. Some of it is just good business — suburbs have dinner traffic, parking, and families who want a proper plate of pasta without a downtown reservation problem. Either way, you don't have to go into the city for the good stuff.
Here's a by-area breakdown of where to eat.
North Shore
Convito Italiano (Wilmette) — One of the oldest Italian spots on the North Shore, open since 1980. The room is casual and the menu runs from simple pasta to rotisserie chicken to a well-sourced cheese and charcuterie selection. The attached Italian market means you can buy olive oil and imported pasta on your way out. Lunch is underrated here — quieter, same kitchen, better value. Located at 1515 Sheridan Road.
Campagnola (Evanston) — A slightly more upscale option on Chicago Avenue in Evanston, known for wood-roasted dishes and a wine list that actually has some thought behind it. The pasta is made in-house, the room is warm without being fussy, and reservations fill up fast on weekends. This is a solid date-night call for the northern suburbs.
Gio (Highland Park) — A neighborhood Italian that's been around long enough to earn regulars. Menu hits the reliable classics — gnocchi, branzino, tiramisu — and the service is attentive without hovering. Not destination dining, but if you live within 20 minutes, it's the kind of place you go every few months and it delivers every time.
Western Suburbs (DuPage County)
La Sorella di Francesca (Naperville) — Part of the Francesca's family of restaurants, which has figured out how to run upscale-casual Italian at a consistent level across multiple suburban locations. La Sorella is the Naperville outpost, and it tends to be the strongest of the group. The mushroom risotto is good. The weekend brunch crowd is intense — go at dinner if you want a table without a 45-minute wait.
Mia Cucina (Oak Brook) — An Italian BYOB in Oak Brook that gets overlooked because it's in a strip mall and doesn't look like much from outside. Inside, the kitchen is serious about housemade pasta and straightforward Italian technique. Bring your own wine, skip the appetizers and go straight to the pasta, and you'll have a very good $50 dinner for two.
Carlucci Rosemont / Downers Grove — Two locations, both reliable for what they are: upscale Italian with white tablecloths, a strong bar program, and a private dining room for groups. The osso buco is a consistent performer. Better for business dinners and special occasions than for casual weeknight pasta.
Lucini Italia (Hinsdale) — A smaller, more personal spot in downtown Hinsdale. The menu rotates based on seasonal availability, which means the food is better but the thing you loved last time might not be there. Strong on handmade pasta. Gets packed on Friday nights.
Northwest Suburbs
Scarpetta's (Schaumburg) — A family-owned Italian place that predates the chain restaurant wave in the northwest suburbs. Red sauce, solid portions, a full bar, and a dining room that actually has space between tables. The chicken parmigiana is what people order here, and it's a good one. Nothing revelatory, but genuinely reliable.
Francesca's Fortunato (Forest Park) — Technically just west of Chicago, but within range for most northwestern suburb residents. This is probably the best of the Francesca's locations — smaller room, tighter menu, less chain-restaurant energy than some of the other outposts. The braised short rib pasta shows up seasonally and is worth ordering when available.
Emilio's (Hillside) — Tapas-style Italian with a wide range of small plates and a wine list focused on Spanish and Italian bottles. The concept sounds confused but the execution isn't. Order six or seven dishes for two people and work through them — it's a better format than a three-course meal at most comparably priced spots.
Southwest Suburbs
D'Agostino's (multiple locations including Tinley Park) — The D'Agostino's brand has deep roots in the southwest suburbs and has expanded into a handful of pizza-forward Italian spots. The thin-crust pizza is legitimately good, the pasta is solid, and the prices are reasonable. This is a family dinner call, not a special occasion one.
Buca di Beppo (Orland Park) — Worth including with the caveat that it's a chain. The food is consistent, portions are enormous, and the family-style format actually works for large groups. If you're feeding eight people at a birthday dinner and you want pasta and tiramisu and nobody leaves hungry, this is a fine call. Just go in knowing what it is.
What to Order and What to Skip
A few general notes on suburban Italian dining:
Handmade pasta matters. The single biggest quality gap between suburban Italian restaurants is whether they're making pasta in-house or pulling it from a bag. Ask, or look for it on the menu. It's not a judgment — it's just useful information that will tell you what to order.
Chicken parmigiana is a useful calibration dish. If a restaurant's chicken parm is good — properly pounded, crispy breading, sauce that tastes like tomatoes, adequate fresh mozzarella — the rest of the menu is probably in order. If it's soggy or undersauced, manage expectations accordingly.
The bread matters more than most people realize. Good suburban Italian spots bring out bread that's actually worth eating before the meal. Mediocre ones bring out rolls that taste like grocery store dinner bread. It's an early signal.
Go for lunch when you can. Most of these restaurants run the same kitchen at lunch for 30 to 40 percent less money and shorter wait times. The Campagnola lunch situation, specifically, is worth taking advantage of.
The Pizza Question
Chicago-area Italian restaurants and Chicago-style pizza exist in a complicated relationship. Some of the places listed above are primarily pizza destinations; others treat pizza as a side category. If your primary goal is deep dish, we've covered the best deep dish pizza in the Chicago suburbs separately. For thin crust and tavern-style, our pizza guide covers that ground more specifically.
For Italian-American sit-down dining — pasta, protein, a bottle of something red, a table for the family — the places above are where to start.
More food guides: Best BYOB Restaurants in Chicago Suburbs · Best Brunch in Schaumburg · All food and drink guides
